CardTrack

Crack and regrade

CGC and BGS slabs that are worth more cracked and regraded at PSA, worked out from real sales.

504 slabs on the board · 73 still profit a grade lower · from prices of 23h ago

🔒 Crack and regrade · Trader

How it works

The same card often sells for less in a CGC or BGS slab than in a PSA one with the same number on it. If the gap is big enough, you can buy the CGC or BGS slab, crack it open, send the card to PSA, and sell the PSA copy for more than everything cost you. You are not hoping for a better grade: the card only has to come back the same, and on the best slabs here it still pays one grade lower.

Every night we check every CGC and BGS 9 and 9.5 we have prices for against the same card's PSA 9, 8 and 7, after PSA's fee and eBay's 13% selling fee. Two real slabs from tonight's board:

Alakazam Skyridge #H1

Alakazam, Skyridge #H1 in a CGC 9

  • You buy the CGC 9 for $1,999, about what the last 5 sold for.
  • You crack it and send the card to PSA. At its value that costs $404, return shipping included.
  • If PSA gives it a 9: it sells for about $3,480, eBay keeps $452, and you are left with $625 profit.
  • If PSA gives it an 8: it sells for about $3,290, eBay keeps $428, and you are left with $460 profit.
  • If PSA gives it a 7: it sells for about $1,080, eBay keeps $140, and you are left with a $1,463 loss.

So even a grade lower pays. The most you can pay for this slab and still break even at a PSA 8 is $2,459.

Blissey HeartGold & SoulSilver #106

Blissey, HeartGold & SoulSilver #106 in a CGC 9

  • You buy the CGC 9 for $199, about what the last 5 sold for.
  • You crack it and send the card to PSA. At its value that costs $111, return shipping included.
  • If PSA gives it a 9: it sells for about $1,150, eBay keeps $150, and you are left with $690 profit.
  • If PSA gives it an 8: it sells for about $350, eBay keeps $46, and you are left with a $6 loss.

So this one only works if PSA agrees it is a 9. Pay no more than $889, and know an 8 leaves you out of pocket.

Before you buy

  • Every price here is what that slab or grade actually sold for recently: completed sales only, at least 3 of them each. Rows marked thin have fewer than 5 sales behind one of the prices, so trust them less.
  • A slab priced more than 8 times below its PSA 9 is flagged: that gap is usually a different printing (a reprint, a stamped or 1st Edition copy), not a bargain.
  • Cards whose PSA prices are out of order (a PSA 8 selling for more than a PSA 9) are left off. So is any grade price the card page itself withholds.
  • What the numbers cannot tell you: the card can come back lower than an 8, it can be damaged when you crack the slab, prices can move while PSA has it, and the copy you buy is not the average copy. A CGC or BGS 9.5 is not counted as a PSA 10 here.
  • The eBay check runs once a day on US Buy It Now. Prices are before shipping and tax, and a listing may have sold since we looked.

Not investment advice.