Carmine — Twilight Masquerade #217, PSA 9

Special Illustration RareTwilight Masquerade217/1672024PSA 9

Carmine 217/167 · Twilight Masquerade PSA 9 price

PSA 9 · mint slab

$54

Fair buy $54 · sell $74Updated today

Grade vs rawFull ladder →

Raw NM$55
PSA 9this page$54
PSA 10$1322.4×

PSA 9 sales: 42; 6 cert-verified
Last 90 days: 21; sells regularly
Confidence: Medium; 21 sales in 90 days, but prices vary widely.
Latest sale: 4d ago; one every ~1d

ViewingPSA 9Raw / ungraded →PSA 10 →

Our published graded price for this card, checked against every cert-verified sale below. An estimate, not an appraisal. How we price →

Set a price alert

We'll email you when this card's value crosses your target.

Alert me when the priceNo password needed — we'll set up your free account.

PSA 9 slabs for sale right now

Live asks for a PSA 9 of this exact card · stock as of today. A raw copy or a reverse holo is a different product and is not in this list.

No live listings in our latest snapshot for this grade — the marketplaces above search it directly.

Buy from here

TCGplayer$50 ebay Fanatics

Affiliate links — CardTrack may earn a commission from eBay and other marketplaces, at no extra cost to you.

Buy#adCardTrack earns a commission on purchasesTCGplayer$50 ebay Fanatics

Why $54? Cert-verified PSA 9 sales

Each sale is tied by PSA to a specific graded slab — click the cert to check the exact card, grade and serial on psacard.com. Outliers against the grade’s own median are dropped; qualified slabs are listed separately beneath.

Date	Sold via	Cert	Price
2026-09-24	eBay · bestoffer	listing #125511166	$64
2026-09-24	Fanatics · bestoffer	#141796616	$40
2026-09-19	eBay · auction	listing #117911901	$43
2026-09-16	eBay · fixedprice	listing #106229612	$70
2026-09-16	eBay · auction	listing #93449733	$33
2026-09-15	eBay · fixedprice	listing #129499253	$64

2 of 6 were competitive auctions; 2 best offers and 2 fixed-price. A PSA 9 copy trades roughly every 1 days, the median gap between cert-verified sales.

PSA 9 price history

Monthly medians of cert-verified PSA 9 sales — 558 sales across 29 months, Jun 2024 to Oct 2026.

PSA 9 · index · latest

$54▼ 21%over 366 days

2025-10-05 → 2026-10-06

The recorded PSA 9 price index, closing on the figure above. The line is the running level, so a single unusually cheap or dear sale does not spike it. Hover any day for its price on the line.

Latest $53 (Oct 2026, 1 sale) · ▼ 56% since Jun 2024

Slab history — PSA 9 copies that have sold more than once

25 slabs have sold more than once, across 25 resales — typically 214 days apart, with a median gross price change of -3.1%. That is 25 of the 504 distinct slabs behind 560 cert-linked sales at this grade — 5%. The rest we have seen sell once, which is not evidence they have not sold before.

Cert	Sales of this slab	Between	Gross change
#147333776	Jun 2026 $115→Sept 2026 $55	3–6 months	-52.2%
#99927093	May 2026 $69→Sept 2026 $32	3–6 months	-54.3%
#125511167	Dec 2025 $49→Sept 2026 $80	6–12 months	+63.3%
#145124078	May 2026 $65→Aug 2026 $63	Under 3 months	-3.1%
#145043373	Mar 2026 $52→Jul 2026 $75	3–6 months	+44.2%
#128776546	Nov 2025 $52→Jul 2026 $80	6–12 months	+53.8%
#104241058	Feb 2025 $71→Jun 2026 $53	Over a year	-25.4%
#105250971	May 2025 $66→May 2026 $90	Over a year	+36.3%
#101881492	Jan 2025 $78→Apr 2026 $63	Over a year	-19.7%
#94343350	Aug 2024 $79→Apr 2026 $60	Over a year	-24.1%

Showing the 10 most recent of 25 slabs with a history. A cert reappearing shows the same physical slab sold again — it identifies no buyer or seller. Gross change is price to price; fees, shipping and the grading cost are not in it.

Every PSA 9 sale we can show you

Cert-verified sales, the eBay comps, our own ledger and Fanatics, in one list newest first. We hold 42 PSA 9 sales with a median of $65; the ledger names its most recent eight, which is what this table can link to. Fanatics alone: 4 PSA 9 sales, 1 in the last 90 days.

GraderGradeCert-verified only 6

	Grade	Venue	Date	Certificate	Price
PSA 9 Pokemon Carmine SIR 217/167	PSA 9	eBay	2026-10-02	—	$53.00
2024 Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Twilight Masquerade SIR Carmine #217 PSA 9 MINT	PSA 9	Fanatics	2026-09-24	—	$42.00
2024 Pokemon TWM en Carmine Special Illustration #217 PSA 9 Mint	PSA 9	eBay	2026-09-24	—	$67.90
2024 Pokémon Twilight Masquerade Carmine 217/167 · PSA 9	PSA 9	Fanatics CollectBestOffer	2026-09-24	141796616	$40.00
2024 Pokémon Twilight Masquerade Carmine 217/167 · PSA 9	PSA 9	eBayBestOffer	2026-09-24	125511166	$64.00
2024 Pokémon Twilight Masquerade Carmine 217/167 · PSA 9	PSA 9	eBayAuction	2026-09-19	117911901	$42.71
2024 Pokémon Twilight Masquerade Carmine 217/167 · PSA 9	PSA 9	eBayAuction	2026-09-16	93449733	$33.00
2024 Pokémon Twilight Masquerade Carmine 217/167 · PSA 9	PSA 9	eBayFixedPrice	2026-09-16	106229612	$69.99
2024 Pokémon Twilight Masquerade Carmine 217/167 · PSA 9	PSA 9	eBayFixedPrice	2026-09-15	129499253	$63.51
92984792 Carmine 2024 Pokemon Twilight Masquerade #217/167 PSA 9	PSA 9	eBay	2026-09-13	—	$49.00
2024 Pokemon Twilight Masquerade Carmine #217/167 PSA 9	PSA 9	eBay	2026-09-13	—	$31.00
The Pokémon Company Carmine 217/167 Sv06 Twilight Masquerade SIR Holo EN PSA 9	PSA 9	eBay	2026-09-04	—	$67.90
2024 Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Twilight Masquerade SIR Carmine #217 PSA 9 MINT	PSA 9	FanaticsAuction	2026-08-10	—	$54.00
2024 Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Twilight Masquerade SIR Carmine #217 PSA 9 MINT	PSA 9	FanaticsAuction	2026-06-15	—	$74.40
2024 Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Twilight Masquerade SIR Carmine #217 PSA 9 MINT	PSA 9	FanaticsAuction	2026-04-06	—	$55.20
2024 Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Twilight Masquerade SIR Carmine #217 PSA 9 MINT	PSA 9	FanaticsAuction	2026-02-09	—	$37.20

1–8 of 16 sales · 6 carry a PSA certificate, checkable on psacard.com.

The ledger’s PSA 9 median ($65) sits above the published price above. The median is every recorded sale weighted equally; the price is the cert-verified market with outliers and qualified slabs removed, and is what the latest sales support.

How many PSA 9 copies exist

PSA’s cumulative census for this card. It counts resubmissions, so it skews toward nicer copies and overstates the rate a fresh submission should expect.

PSA 9 population

3,457

41.5% of 8,324 graded

Graded higher

4,004

PSA 10s above this grade

Total PSA graded

8,324

every grade, all time

Other graders at a 9: TAG 95 of 213. A CGC or BGS 9 is its own market and is not in the price above.

Is Carmine worth grading?

Every grade weighted by how often this card actually earns it — the PSA 9 outcome is one leg, not the whole answer.

Verdict

Not worth it

every grade weighted by its census share

Expected net

$-44

after fees, all grades

Comes back PSA 9

4090%

of submissions, by the census

PSA 9 outcome

$-82

PSA 9 net of raw and fee

Grading cost

$81

tier fee + shipping

Trader

Compare graders, and the live market

The verdict above is PSA's — the grader the population, the ROI table and the ladder on this page all use. Trader prices all three graders against each other and adds what the asking market is doing right now.

Trader plan and above →

PSA, CGC and Beckett side by side — each on its own population and fees, Beckett scored on the 9.5 its market pays for.
Lightly and moderately played — the same expected return for a copy that cannot gem.
Ask vs sold — what the live listings want, against what copies have really closed at.
Momentum — the 30-day median against the 90-day, per grade.
Where it sells higher — the Fanatics-versus-eBay premium, with the sale counts behind it.
Population history — the weekly PSA census, so you can see how fast 10s are arriving before you post the card.

Built on 144 graded sales and a population of 5,118,970 · fees as of 2026-10-03.

More Carmine and more from Twilight Masquerade

Prices are raw near mint; PSA 10 shown where we have one.

Cite this PSA 9 pricefree with attribution

Citation

Carmine (Twilight Masquerade #217) — PSA 9 market value USD $54, from 6 cert-verified sales. Source: CardTrack, https://cardtrack.com/pokemon/card/twilight-masquerade/carmine-217/psa-9

Embed this on your site

<iframe src="https://cardtrack.com/embed/card?id=sv6-217" width="100%" height="160" style="border:0;max-width:460px" title="Carmine PSA 9 price — CardTrack" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font:12px system-ui">Source: <a href="https://cardtrack.com">CardTrack</a></p>

Frequently asked questions

How much is a PSA 9 Carmine (Twilight Masquerade #217) worth?

As of 6 October 2026, a PSA 9 mint Carmine from Twilight Masquerade is worth approximately $54, with a fair range of $54 to $74 — about 1.0× the $55 raw near-mint price.

Where does the PSA 9 price come from?

From 6 cert-verified PSA 9 sales, each tied by PSA to a specific slab with a public cert number — 2 at auction, 2 by best offer and 2 at a fixed price. A PSA 9 copy trades roughly every 1 days.

How many PSA 9 Carmine exist?

PSA has graded 3,457 copies of Carmine (Twilight Masquerade #217) a 9, out of 8,324 submitted — 41.5% of the population, with 4,004 graded higher. The census counts resubmissions, so it overstates the gem rate a fresh submission should expect.

Should I grade my Carmine hoping for a PSA 9?

Probably not. Weighting every grade by how often this card earns it, expected value after the $81 grading fee is about $-44; this card comes back a PSA 9 about 4090% of the time.

Is a PSA 9 Carmine a good investment?

CardTrack tracks prices; it does not give investment advice. A PSA 9 Carmine has 42 recorded sales, 21 of them in the last 90 days, and the slab-history table above shows what happened to copies that sold twice. Read those before you read anyone's forecast.