CardTrack
19 other Butterfree printings exist — is this your card? HeartGold & SoulSilver 16/123 ↓

RareHeartGold & SoulSilver16/1232010Illustrated by Tomokazu KomiyaAll Butterfree cards

Butterfree #16/123 HeartGold & SoulSilver Price

Butterfree — HeartGold & SoulSilver #16

Raw · near mint

$14.97

Not near mint? Value by condition or grade ↓

▲ 1.0% 30 daysUpdated

Graded

  • PSA 10estimate$255
  • PSA 9estimate$83
Sales recorded
104
every grade, since 2025
Last 90 days · raw
49 sales
50 across every grade · 17 in the last 30
Confidence
Medium
Prices vary widely.
Latest sale
18 Nov 2026
raw

PSA population1 PSA 10s12 gradedas of What the rate means →

ViewingRaw / ungradedReverse Holo →

Based on 50 qualified completed sales across every grade in the last 90 days. Sold prices, not asking: the near-mint figure comes from completed sales of this exact card. An estimate, not an appraisal. How we price →

What's your copy worth?

Pick the holder and condition you have. How the grades are judged → How we price played copies →

Not sure which condition? Grade it from a photo →

What an ungraded copy has done.

Raw · latest

$14.97▲ 72%over 366 days

2025-11-18 → 2026-11-19

$8
$10
$12
$14
18 NovJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOct19 Nov
Our recorded ungraded price for this card. The line closes on the Near Mint figure shown above — the chart and the headline are the same number by construction, never two. The line is the running level, so a single unusually cheap or dear sale does not spike it. Hover any day for its price on the line.

Butterfree price history

The near-mint price at the end of each month, from the same recorded line as the chart, newest first. The latest month closes on the price at the top of this page.

Butterfree (HeartGold & SoulSilver 16/123) near-mint price by month
MonthNear-mint priceChange on month
November 2026to 19 Nov 2026$14.97−0.0%
October 2026$14.97+1.0%
September 2026$14.82—
April 2026$9.38−5.6%
March 2026$9.93+6.4%
February 2026$9.33−16.8%
January 2026$11.22+14.9%
December 2025$9.77+26.4%
November 2025$7.73−3.7%
October 2025$8.03+7.2%
September 2025$7.49+0.0%
August 2025$7.49+0.0%

How Butterfree trades

A near-mint Butterfree is 53% more expensive than a year ago, when our recorded sales put it at $9.77 (December 2025). That is the highest it has been in our price history, which goes back to January 2021.

Copies for sale right now

Asking prices, not sales.

Buy from here

Affiliate links — CardTrack may earn a commission from eBay and other marketplaces, at no extra cost to you.

Buy#adCardTrack earns a commission on purchasesTCGplayer$20ebayFanatics

Affiliate links — CardTrack may earn a commission from eBay and other marketplaces, at no extra cost to you. Prices shown across this page are sold-based, not sponsored placements.

Cheapest raw copy $9 (condition not stated — like-for-like only if it is near mint) — 38% below our near-mint estimate of $15 · 8 copies whose seller declares wear left out of that comparison

Stock as of .

What the sales actually show

Momentum

0%

Raw — 30d vs 90d median

Where it sells

100% eBay

Raw — last 90 days

Demand

71/100

Very liquid — sales rate, trend & buzz

Population

How many copies each grader has graded, every grade, all time. A population counts what has been graded, not every copy that exists, and resubmissions count again.

PSA graded
12
+1 in 4 weeks
PSA 10
1
no change, in 4 weeks
PSA 9
6
no change, in 4 weeks
Historical PSA 10 rate
—
PSA 10s of all graded

Graded market cap $1.9K: every PSA, CGC and Beckett slab of this card we can price, at today’s price for its grade, all printings together. That is under 0.05% of the $10.10B graded Pokémon market.

GraderGraded10s9s10s share
PSA1216—
CGC1506—
SGC202—
PSA graded
12
10s
1
10s share
—
every 10 label
Historical PSA 10 rate
—
Every PSA grade (5)
PSA population by grade
GradeCopiesShare
1018.3%
9650.0%
8325.0%
718.3%
318.3%

PSA’s count of 15 Nov 2026. The rate is PSA 10s over every copy PSA has graded.

CGC graded
15
10s
0
10s share
—
every 10 label
Historical CGC gem rate
—
gem: 10s, Pristine and Perfect 10s
Every CGC grade (8)
CGC population by grade
GradeCopiesShare
9.516.7%
9640.0%
8.516.7%
8320.0%
6.516.7%
5.516.7%
216.7%
Authentic16.7%

CGC’s count of 18 Nov 2026, from GemRate. 10s share counts every 10 label; CGC’s own gem is 10s, Pristine and Perfect 10s.

SGC graded
2
10s
0
10s share
—
every 10 label
Historical SGC gem rate
—
gem: 10s and Pristine 10s
Every SGC grade (1)
SGC population by grade
GradeCopiesShare
92100.0%

SGC’s count of 18 Nov 2026, from GemRate. 10s share counts every 10 label; SGC’s own gem is 10s and Pristine 10s.

PSA’s count of 15 Nov 2026. CGC, Beckett and SGC as of 18 Nov 2026, from GemRate. CGC, Beckett and SGC 10s include Pristine, Perfect and Black Label 10s. How population is measured →

PSA 10 price against PSA’s population

The same 13 weeks, 24 Jul 2026 to 16 Nov 2026: the recorded PSA 10 price on the day of each weekly PSA report, and the report’s graded count. Side by side, not cause and effect.

PSA 10 price
$222$218
24 Jul 202616 Nov 2026
PSA graded copies
1211
24 Jul 202616 Nov 2026

Is Butterfree worth grading?

Every grade weighted by how often this card has actually earned it, each at its own fee tier. An average over a distribution, not a promise about your copy.

Not worth grading: expected return $-27 after fees, all grades weighted.

PSA 10, net

$157

$255 slab less $83 grading and the $15 raw card

PSA 9, net

$-13

$83 slab less $81 grading and the raw card

Estimated PSA 10 rate

8.3%

of 12 copies PSA has graded

Break-even raw price

$0

pay more than this for the raw card and grading loses money on average

PSA population

12

1 PSA 10s, PSA’s count of 15 Nov 2026

PSA 10 at $255 is the catalogue figure, sales to 18 Nov 2026; 6 graded sales in the ledger. Raw price as of 19 Nov 2026. PSA fees as of 26 Sept 2026, the tier for each grade’s own value plus insured shipping. The PSA 10 count has not moved 5% in 90 days.

Want an alert for this card?Not built yet: a click counts your interest, nothing is sent.

Work it through for your copy: grading calculator, grading simulator (both set to this card) or the grading planner.

Recent sales

The latest sales at each grade, newest first. Pick a grade.

Item soldGradeVenueDateCertificatePrice
HeartGold SoulSilver #16/123 Butterfree NMRawNMeBay2026-11-18—$15.99
Pokémon TCG, Butterfree, HeartGold SoulSilver, 16/123, Komiya Art, NMRawNMeBay2026-11-18—$11.89
Tomokazu Komiya - Butterfree 16/123 HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon NMRawNMeBay2026-11-14—$20.16
Butterfree 16/123 Rare HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon Heavily PlayedRawHPeBay2026-11-14—$7.71
Butterfree 16/123 Rare HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon CUTE Tomokazu Komiya NM/LPRawLPeBay2026-11-14—$11.50
Butterfree HeartGold SoulSilver Regular Card 16/123RawNMeBay2026-11-09—$10.99
Butterfree HeartGold & SoulSilver 16/123 LP Pokemon 2010RawLPeBay2026-11-08—$11.99
Pokémon Butterfree 16/123 HeartGold SoulSilver 2010 Rare Non-Holo LPRawLPeBay2026-11-08—$6.30
Butterfree 16/123 Rare HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon Lightly PlayedRawLPeBay2026-11-07—$11.99
Butterfree - 16/123 - Pokemon HeartGold SoulSilver Non-Holo Card! NMRawNMeBay2026-11-05—$15.35
Butterfree - 16/123 - HeartGold SoulSilver Non-Holo - HPRawHPeBay2026-11-02—$2.89
Pokemon Butterfree 16/123 HeartGold SoulSilver Regular CardRawLPeBay2026-10-31—$9.00
Butterfree 16/123 Rare HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon Lightly PlayedRawLPeBay2026-10-30—$11.00
Butterfree 16/123 Rare HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon Lightly PlayedRawLPeBay2026-10-29—$9.99
Butterfree 16/123 Rare HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon Moderately PlayedRawMPeBay2026-10-25—$5.99

1–15 of 30 sales. Condition tags are what the seller stated, in the title or in eBay’s card-condition field; the Near Mint price is formed from the NM sales, so played and unstated copies can sit below it. “Not stated · NM price” marks a sale whose seller said nothing but that sold at or above 90% of the near-mint price.

Frequently asked questions

How much is Butterfree (HeartGold & SoulSilver 16/123) worth?

As of 19 November 2026, Butterfree from HeartGold & SoulSilver is worth about $14.97 ungraded in near-mint condition, and about $255 as a PSA 10. Blended from real completed sales and live market prices, updated daily.

Is Butterfree going up or down?

A near-mint Butterfree is up 1.0% over the last 30 days, and up 100% since August 2025, when it was $7.49. The month-by-month prices are in the price history table on this page.

How often does Butterfree sell?

We recorded 50 completed sales of this card across every grade in the last 90 days, 49 of them raw. The latest raw sale was on 18 Nov 2026.

Is Butterfree worth grading?

Probably not. Weighting every grade by how often this card actually earns it, grading works out to an expected loss of about $27.00 after fees.

What set is Butterfree from?

Butterfree is card 16/123 in HeartGold & SoulSilver, released in 2010, rarity Rare, illustrated by Tomokazu Komiya.

More Butterfree and more from HeartGold & SoulSilver

Prices are raw near mint; PSA 10 shown where we have one.