Rare

Nightmare Limited Edition Alpha #118

Card #118 · Illustrated by Melissa A. Benson · Black Colour

Market value · ungraded

$1,399.99

Blended from live market data · graded from real sold data
Confidence high · estimate, not an appraisal · How we price →

Buy from here

TCGplayer ebay Cardmarket

Nightmare is a Rare Magic: The Gathering card from Limited Edition Alpha (#118), illustrated by Melissa A. Benson. Its current blended market value is $1,399.99 ungraded. Prices update from real market data.

Graded prices

No BGS 9 or BGS 10 price yet — too few verified gem-grade sales to price the top grades reliably. They'll appear here once enough real sold results back them.

BGS graded price estimates by grade
Grade	Relative value	Price
BGS 8.5		$1,350$1,300–$1,400
BGS 8		$1,150$1,150–$1,150

“Sold” = median of real recent sold listings at that grade (eBay or Fanatics Collect — hover a badge to see which). Other figures are blended marketplace estimates. Confidence reflects source backing and price spread — not PSA-official values.

What this price is based on

Low confidence

Only 2 sales in the last 90 days.

Median · BGS 8.5$1,3502 sales

Trimmed mean$1,350outliers removed

Range$1,300 – $1,400lowest to highest sale

Sales rate0.7/mo4 recorded

Recent BGS 8.5 sales

Jul 6, 2026Fanatics$1,400
Jul 6, 2026Fanatics$1,300

By grade

BGS 8.5$1,3502 sales
CGC 6.5$1,7001 sale
BGS 8$1,1501 sale

From 4 completed sales recorded between Jun 30, 2026 and Jul 6, 2026. Sold prices only — asking prices are never counted.

Grade it or not

Not enough graded evidence yet — 4 graded sales recorded.

✨ Is it worth it?

An AI market read of this card — value, momentum, grading economics, liquidity. It lays out the data; you decide.

Price history · raw near-mint

1 Sept 202121 Aug 2026

Latest

$1,399.99

Period high

$1,399.99

Period low

$0.62

Change

▲ 69899.5%

Recent Fanatics auction sales

GradeItemSoldTypePrice

BGS 8.51993 Magic The Gathering MTG Alpha Nightmare BGS 8.5 NM-MT+2026-07-06BIN$1,400

BGS 8.51993 Magic The Gathering MTG Alpha Nightmare BGS 8.5 NM-MT+2026-07-06BIN$1,300

BGS 81993 Magic The Gathering MTG Alpha Nightmare BGS 8 NM-MT2026-07-06BIN$1,150

3 Fanatics Collect sales matched to this card.

See live Fanatics auctions →

Available to buy nowLive on eBay

Card details

Set: Limited Edition Alpha
Number: #118
Rarity: Rare
Illustrator: Melissa A. Benson
Colour: Black
Game: Magic: The Gathering

More from Limited Edition Alpha

All Limited Edition Alpha cards →

Where to buy & check prices

Check recent sold prices

eBay sold

Frequently asked questions

How much is Nightmare worth?

Nightmare (Limited Edition Alpha #118) is worth around $1,399.99 ungraded, based on live Magic: The Gathering market data.

Where can I buy Nightmare?

You can buy Nightmare on TCGplayer, Cardmarket and eBay — see the live listings on this page. Always compare against the blended market value first.

What rarity is Nightmare?

Nightmare is a Rare Magic: The Gathering card from the Limited Edition Alpha set, illustrated by Melissa A. Benson.

Cite & embed this card

Free to use with attribution to CardTrack.

Citation

Nightmare (Limited Edition Alpha #118) — Magic: The Gathering market value $1,399.99. Source: CardTrack, https://cardtrack.com/magic/card/limited-edition-alpha/nightmare-118

Embed this on your site

<iframe src="https://cardtrack.com/embed/card?id=LEA-118" width="100%" height="160" style="border:0;max-width:460px" title="Nightmare price — CardTrack" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font:12px system-ui">Source: <a href="https://cardtrack.com">CardTrack</a></p>