Island Secret Lair Drop #1940
Confidence high · estimate, not an appraisal · How we price →
Island is a Rare Magic: The Gathering card from Secret Lair Drop (#1940), illustrated by Jon Vermilyea. Its current blended market value is $6.03 ungraded, with a PSA 10 worth around $58. Prices update from real market data.
| Grade | Relative value | Price |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | $58$58–$58 | |
| PSA 9 | $11$11–$11 |
What this price is based on
Medium confidence19 sales in 90 days, but prices vary widely.
Recent Raw sales
- Aug 12, 2026eBay — Island (GARY) ✨ Rainbow FOIL ✨ MTG NM Secret Lair SPONGEBOB SQUAREPANTS (1940)NM$14.99
- Aug 9, 2026eBay — MTG Island RAINBOW FOIL Secret Lair Drop x SpongeBob 1940 NMNM$19.98
- Aug 6, 2026eBay — 1x Island ✨ Rainbow FOIL 🌈✨ MTG NM Secret Lair SPONGEBOB SQUAREPANTS (1940)NM$13.99
- Aug 6, 2026eBay — Island (1940) (Rainbow Foil) Secret Lair Drop Foil$9.99
- Aug 1, 2026eBay — Island (1940) (Rainbow Foil) Secret Lair Drop Foil$9.99
- Jul 21, 2026eBay — Island (1940) FOIL Spongebob Secret Lair Lands Under the Sea SLD - NMNM$12.69
- Jul 20, 2026eBay — 2025 MTG Magic the Gathering SLD Secret Lair Drop SpongeBob Foil #1940 Island$11.99
- Jul 15, 2026eBay — Island (1940) (Rainbow Foil) #1940 (NM) Secret Lair Drop SLD Magic MTGNM$8.59
From 22 completed sales recorded between Apr 9, 2026 and Aug 12, 2026. Sold prices only — asking prices are never counted. The range is wide because these sales span different printings and conditions — 1st Edition, Shadowless and Unlimited copies all carry this card's name, and they trade at very different levels. Each sale above is labelled with what its listing claimed, so you can see which ones describe the same object. Treat the median as the typical copy, not the range.
Grade it or not
Not enough graded evidence yet — 0 graded sales recorded.
✨ Is it worth it?
An AI market read of this card — value, momentum, grading economics, liquidity. It lays out the data; you decide.
Price history · raw near-mint
Card details
- Number
- #1940
- Rarity
- Rare
- Illustrator
- Jon Vermilyea
More from Secret Lair Drop
Where to buy & check prices
Frequently asked questions
How much is Island worth?
Island (Secret Lair Drop #1940) is worth around $6.03 ungraded, or about $58 in PSA 10, based on live Magic: The Gathering market data.
What is a PSA 10 Island worth?
A PSA 10 Island sells for around $58, roughly 10× the ungraded price.
Where can I buy Island?
You can buy Island on TCGplayer, Cardmarket and eBay — see the live listings on this page. Always compare against the blended market value first.
What rarity is Island?
Island is a Rare Magic: The Gathering card from the Secret Lair Drop set, illustrated by Jon Vermilyea.
Cite & embed this card
Free to use with attribution to CardTrack.
Island (Secret Lair Drop #1940) — Magic: The Gathering market value $6.03, PSA 10 $57.99. Source: CardTrack, https://cardtrack.com/magic/card/secret-lair-drop/island-1940<iframe src="https://cardtrack.com/embed/card?id=SLD-1940" width="100%" height="160" style="border:0;max-width:460px" title="Island price — CardTrack" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font:12px system-ui">Source: <a href="https://cardtrack.com">CardTrack</a></p>