The Watcher in the Water Tales of Middle-earth Promos #75 (Foil)
Confidence high · estimate, not an appraisal · How we price →
The Watcher in the Water is a Mythic Magic: The Gathering card from Tales of Middle-earth Promos (#75), illustrated by Chris Cold. Its current blended market value is $6.05 ungraded, with a PSA 10 worth around $125. Prices update from real market data.
| Grade | Relative value | Price |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | $125$125–$125 |
What this price is based on
Medium confidence5 sales in 90 days — enough for a guide, not a guarantee.
Recent Raw sales
- Jul 24, 2026eBay — The Watcher in the Water #75 (Foil) (NM) Lord of the Rings LTR Magic MTGNM$5.29
- Jul 16, 2026eBay — Foil The Watcher in the Water - 75 - MP - Universes Beyond: The Lord of the R...MP$3.99
- Jul 3, 2026eBay — The Watcher in the Water #75 (Foil) (NM) Lord of the Rings LTR Magic MTGNM$8.29
- Jun 22, 2026eBay — The Watcher in the Water #75 (Foil) (NM) Lord of the Rings LTR Magic MTGNM$4.69
- Jun 2, 2026eBay — The Watcher in the Water Foil #75 Lord of the Rings 250001$3.99
- May 22, 2026eBay — The Watcher in the Water #75 (Foil) (NM) Lord of the Rings LTR Magic MTGNM$4.50
From 6 completed sales recorded between May 22, 2026 and Jul 24, 2026. Sold prices only — asking prices are never counted.
Grade it or not
Not enough graded evidence yet — 0 graded sales recorded.
✨ Is it worth it?
An AI market read of this card — value, momentum, grading economics, liquidity. It lays out the data; you decide.
Price history · raw near-mint
Card details
- Number
- #75
- Rarity
- Mythic
- Illustrator
- Chris Cold
- Colour
- Blue
More from Tales of Middle-earth Promos
Where to buy & check prices
Frequently asked questions
How much is The Watcher in the Water worth?
The Watcher in the Water (Tales of Middle-earth Promos #75) is worth around $6.05 ungraded, or about $125 in PSA 10, based on live Magic: The Gathering market data.
What is a PSA 10 The Watcher in the Water worth?
A PSA 10 The Watcher in the Water sells for around $125, roughly 21× the ungraded price.
Where can I buy The Watcher in the Water?
You can buy The Watcher in the Water on TCGplayer, Cardmarket and eBay — see the live listings on this page. Always compare against the blended market value first.
What rarity is The Watcher in the Water?
The Watcher in the Water is a Mythic Magic: The Gathering card from the Tales of Middle-earth Promos set, illustrated by Chris Cold.
Cite & embed this card
Free to use with attribution to CardTrack.
The Watcher in the Water (Tales of Middle-earth Promos #75) — Magic: The Gathering market value $6.05, PSA 10 $125.00. Source: CardTrack, https://cardtrack.com/magic/card/tales-of-middle-earth-promos/the-watcher-in-the-water-75<iframe src="https://cardtrack.com/embed/card?id=PLTR-75s" width="100%" height="160" style="border:0;max-width:460px" title="The Watcher in the Water price — CardTrack" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font:12px system-ui">Source: <a href="https://cardtrack.com">CardTrack</a></p>